Voting for change

Share |
Great Britain went to the polls yesterday and today it is waking up to what looks like being a hung parliament. It may take days or even weeks for negotiations to form a coalition government to be completed. At worst, the Queen may have to exercise her powers and call for another general election. However, that is not the only big story to come out of the election.

In many polling booths around the country the unexpected high turnout of voters caught polling booth electoral officers completely off guard. This resulted in many voters giving up or being turned away as the polls closed. These people were angry and felt disenfranchised and the exercise highlighted just how archaic and inconvenient having to travel to vote is.

Apart from postal voting, which is also inconvenient, there is little choice. Why? What’s wrong with internet or mobile voting nowadays. If it’s good enough for American Idol, which attracts hundreds of millions of votes each year, why isn’t it good enough to vote for governments?

We use similar technology for banking, buying, document exchange, email, communicating, etc. etc.  Surely we could allow everyone registered to vote to use the internet and mobile phones. The idea is fine but the arguments will start about security and vote fixing, etc., big deal, that happens with the current system.  Most people in developed countries have access to the technology and if they don’t they could go to a polling both as they do now.

The government already has a record of each eligible voter and they check them off the register when they vote. These voters could be given the option of voting ‘electronically’ and be given a unique ID number or use their current social security or tax ID if they already have one. They would then be issued with a unique PIN to be used when casting their votes. Voting by SMS, browser or application could be easily achieved when you consider what else we can do already.

The benefits are many. Reduced cost of holding elections, savings on petrol not having to drive to the polls, instant tally capability, potential reduction of fraud, more accurate counts, less lost votes - the list goes on.

So what are we awaiting for?  We keep hearing of the need for new applications to keep mobile operators’ revenues flowing. Even at a nominal charge of 5 cents or 5 pence per vote, for example, this could really be the ‘killer app’ we have been waiting for. Has any country out there already introduced this form of voting? 

Posted 05-07-2010 9:32 AM by The Insider

Comments

Eric Priezkalns wrote re: Voting for change
on 05-09-2010 2:12 AM

The UK has already run extensive pilots of so-called 'e-voting' in actual elections - the 2007 European Elections, if my memory is correct.  Needless to say, they were not a complete success.  Whilst I agree with your overall thrust - voters should be given the choice - the results of the pilots dampen my enthusiasm.

Problems highlighted by the trials included (1) insufficient transparency of how the code in proprietary systems actually works (leading to concerns about exploitable but unknown weaknesses), and (2) insufficient planning and insufficient training of staff responsible for running the elections leaving them unable to handle issues as they arose (apart from looking stupidly at a screen and saying "don't ask me").

Opaque and quirky proprietary systems?  No knowledge transfer to the supposed customer?  Sounds like most other ICT implementations to me.

We welcome your feedback! To comment on this blog post please either Log-In or Register to the TM Forum Community

Paid Advertisement
About TM Forum
Introduction, History, Board, Management Team...
Membership
How to Join, Benefits, Member List...
Community
Community Home, Groups & Teams, Blogs...
Conferences
Event Calendar, Management World, Supported Events...
Training & Webcasts
Upcoming Training Courses, Upcoming Webinars, Podcasts, On-Demand Webcasts...
Initiatives
Cable, Enabling Cloud Services, Government and Defense...
Best Practices & Standards
Frameworx, Business Process Framework (eTOM), Information Framework (SID)...
Resources
Document Library, Case Studies, White Papers
Research & Publications
Business Benchmarking, Newsletters, Insights Research...
Copyright © 1988-2012, TeleManagement Forum. All Rights Reserved
Contact Us
Careers with TM Forum
News Room
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Sitemap